CDPH
(Collection Due Process Hearing)

Robert Clarkson 864-225-3061    email Nelson Waller 864-225-0882

CDPH PACKET

All the information and tactics you need to win your Collection Due Process Hearing

  1. (New) Clarkson’s Due Process of Law - DVD $30
  2. Audit Procedure I - VHS or DVD $30; Clarkson’s procedural method to battle bureaucracies
  3. Earnest Letter Writing and Sneaky Lawyer Tricks - CD Text $30 Shows you how to fend off bureaucrats and protect the record.
  4. How to Beat the IRS - Dr. Clarkson speech on successful and proven methods – DVD $20

All of these for $100, including S&H. This is normally a $120 deal!

Ordering Instructions:
Send cash (wrapped in colored paper) or check/money order with payee line blank. Send to: Robert Clarkson, PO Box 2368, Anderson, SC 29621

Or click here for order form.


Table of Contents

  1. Ready to use forms plus instructions:
    1. OLD CDPH request form-ready to use
    2. Clarkson's instructions for NEW blank CDPH Form
    3. Sample NEW CDPH form
    4. NEW blank CDPH form with IRS instructions (typable PDF file)
    5. Attachment to CDPH Form
    6. Indigence Letter
    7. Petition to File in Tax Court
    8. Petition for Re-Determination on Notice of Determination
    9. Request to Agency to Remove Levy on Failure of CDPH
  2. Cases We've Won--Magnificient Clarkson Victories
    1. Noel's Face to Face Hearing
    2. Tax Court Rules In-person Hearing is Mandatory
    3. Circuit Court Rebukes District Court and DOJ in Atlanta
    4. Shell's Response to CDP Hearing
    5. Marett Order for Face to Face Hearing
    6. Patriot pro se beats DOJ in Circuit Court on CDPH Appeal
    7. Guido's Great Victory!
    8. Paul's Victory
    9. John and Trudy's Victory
    10. Beverly's Great Victory (10 out of 10!)
    11. Vidya's Victory
    Subscribe to PN-CDPH Club e-group
    Powered by groups.yahoo.com

    This part is now password protected. Call Dr. Clarkson for the access code and then click here.

  3. Response to Appeals Division Letters
    1. New Response to Appeals Letter
    2. Attachment to CDPH Form
    3. Response to Appeals on Missing Request Form
    4. Reply to Appeals Dvision
    5. Response to Appeals Letter
    6. Alternative CDPH Response Letter
    7. David Patriot Alternative CDPH Response Letter
    8. Recall and Substitute Letter
    9. The Recall Letter
    10. Scott Patriot's Response to Appeals Decision
    11. Response to Appeals on Recall Letter
    12. IRS Appeals Office 'Trash Letter'
    13. Second Response to Appeals
    14. Response to Appeals "Trash Letter"
    15. Another Response to "Trash Letter"
  4. CDPH Appeals in Tax Court:
    1. Suing in Tax Court:
      1. Petition for Re-Determination of Notice of Determination on CDPH
      2. Supplement to Tax Court Petition
      3. New Law on CDPH
      4. Filing and Indigent Cover Letter
      5. TC's Indigency Application for Waiver of Filing Fees
    2. Trudy's CDPH Appeal
      1. Trudy Patriot's Petition of Re-Determination
      2. Trudy Patriot's Reply to Answer
      3. Trudy Patriot's Status Report of CDP Hearing
    3. Scott's CDPH Appeal
      1. Petition for Re-Determination of Notice of Determination on CDPH
      2. Supplement to Petition for CDPH
      3. Response to Threat of Summary Judgment
    4. Wane Patriot's CDPH Appeal
      1. Opposition to Motion for Summary Judgment
      2. Supplement to Tax Court Redetermination
      3. Wayne Patriot's Status Report
      4. Motion for Reconsideration
    5. Chris Freeman
      1. Supplement to CDPH Appeal
    6. Ernie Patriot §6320 case on NFTL
      1. Opposition to Motion for Summary Judgment
      2. Supplement to Tax Court Petition
    7. Janet A. Patriot's Case
      1. Janet's Opposition to Government's Motion
      2. Janet's Supplement to CDPH Petition
    8. William Freeman's §6330 Case in Tax Court
      1. Motion for Continuance for Slow Stipulations
      2. Opposition to Motion for Summary Judgment
    9. Vilas Freeman's Case
      1. Supplement to Petition for Lien and Levy Action
      2. Answer to petition by CIR
      3. Answer to Amended Petition by CIR
    10. Vidya Freeman's Case
      1. Vidya Freeman Supplement to Petition
      2. Vidya's Reply to Answer
      3. Reply to Answer to Supplement
      4. Answer to Amended Petition
    11. G.A. Patriot's Case
      1. Supplement to Petition
      2. A's Motion for Summary Judgment
      3. Confirmation Letter
      4. Motion for Reconsideration of Order
      5. Objection to Motion to Remand
      6. Supplement to Petition for Lien and Levy Action
      7. Answer to petition by CIR
      8. Answer to Amended Petition by CIR
    12. Daniel Patriot's Case
      1. Opposition to Motion for Summary Judgment
    13. Patriot Paralegal Sheri's Case
      1. Supplement on Face to Face
    14. Paul Freeman's Case
      1. Supplement to Petition on Recall Letter
      2. Supplement to Amended Petition
    15. Ted Patriot's Case
      1. Ted's Final Motion
      2. Ted's Reply to Objection to Motion to Vacate
    16. James Patriot's Case
      1. James Patriot's Motion for Reconsideration
    17. David Patriot's Case
      1. David Patriot's Supplement to CDPH Petition
    18. Warren Patriot
      1. Answer by IRS to Petition and Supplement
      2. Reply to IRS's Answer
      3. Letter for Pre-Trial Meeting
      4. Status Report on Tax Court Case
    19. Noel Patriot's Case
      1. Pre-trial Memorandum by IRS
    20. Sheri Patriot's Case
      1. Sheri's Supplement to Petition
      2. CIR Answer to Supplement
    21. Debra Patriot's Case
      1. Reply to Answer to Amended Petition
    22. Gary Smith
      1. Motion To Reinstate and Motion To Vacate
  5. Instructions and IRS Positions
    1. General Instructions
    2. New Changes by IRS on CDPH Procedure
      1. Dec 06 Changes by IRS on CDPH Procedure(Aug 06 Requires Adobe Reader.)
      2. New Regulations on Hearings under 6320 Liens
      3. New Regulations on Hearings under 6330 Levies
      4. Dec 06 New Regs Explained - Law Review Article (Requires Adobe Reader.)
    3. Some Q & A on CDPH
    4. DPH: IRS criteria for hearing Request.
    5. How the IRS Explains CDPH
    6. Information from IRS Counsel on CDPH
    7. Proof of Receipt of NOD
    8. IRS Instructions on Secondary CDPH Notice
    9. IRS' Instructions on Litigation for §6320 and §6330
    10. TIGTA on IRS Compliance with Liens § 6320 (2006)
  6. Hearings and Conferences
    1. Certificate of Witness to Court Hearing
  7. The Problems and Issues:
    1. Face to Face Hearing:
      1. Definition of a "Hearing"
      2. In House Hearing:
            Why you are entitled to a face to face collection hearing.
      3. Sample Letter CDPH Hearing
            More reasons why you are entitled to a face to face collection hearing.
      4. Face To Face CDPH (from the IRS)
            More reasons why you are entitled to a face to face collection hearing.
    2. Tape Recording:
      1. Tape Recordings of Conferences
      2. Keene Case
      3. Article On Keene case
      4. Recording Not Required for Frivolous Arguements
      5. Right to Record Mandates a Hearing
    3. Failure to send NOD
      1. Incorrect Address Brief
      2. Response to Appeal on Incorrect Addreses
      3. Post Office Form for IRS to File on Missing NOD
        1. Clarkson's Instructions on Post Office Form for Missing NOD
        2. Post Office Form
  8. Schulz II Case and Motions
    1. chulz II Case: (Requires Adobe Reader)
      Case Cite: 413 F.3d 297(2d)NY), 95 A.F.T.R.2d 2005-3007, 2005 WL 152090
    2. Comments on Schulz II Case
    3. Dr. C.'s Schulz II Brief
    4. Noel Schulz II Brief
    5. John Patriot's Schulz II Brief
  9. CDPH Information from IRS:
    1. IRS Video on 'The Appeals Process':
      This is a 9 minute video clip on IRS collection procedure, the appeals process and the IRS Office of Appeals. General information, not very useful but easy to understand. Requires Media Player.
    2. IRS Video on 'The Collection Appeals Process':
      This is a collection of regulations, pamphlets, video's etc from the thieving tax collectors which explains their lies to the foolish sheeple. Part of this is interesting; some has actual, useful information; most is lies and a little is truthful! Requires Media Player.
  10. The Law on CDPH:
    1. The Statute Law on Levies §6330     (Important. Read carefully.)
    2. The Regulations on Levies §6330
    3. The Statute Law on Liens §6320
    4. The Regulations on Liens §6320
    5. Item 21: Verification of the Accuracy of the Tax Liability
  11. Important Cases On CDPH
    1. Important Tax Court case on CPDH.
          (Several important details and quotes.) (Note: needs Acrobat Reader.)
    2. Lee vs. CIR on bad CDPHs
    3. Tax Court Judge Requires In-Person Hearing
  12. Interesting Commentaries
    1. Article by Diane and the Lee Case
    2. Article on Katz case
    3. More Ways to Beat a CDPH
    4. CPA Explanation of Robinette Case
  13. Tax Court Cases:
    1. The Orum Case
    2. Montijo v. United States (a most unusual win!)
    3. Tax Court Rules Hearing is Mandatory: Meyers vs. CIR
    4. IRS Violates Bankruptcy Court's Stay: Meadows vs. CIR
  14. Law Review Articles on CDPH:
    1. Determining the Meaning of a Meaningful Collection Due Process, by P. Kesner
    2. How Much Process is Due? I.R.C. Sections 6320 & 6330 CDPH, by D. Cords
    3. Houston Law Review: CDPH Rights, by Leslie Book
    4. University of Cincinnati Law Review: CDPH Judicial Review, by Danshera Cords
    5. Baylor Law Review: The Tax Court's Jurisdiction Over Due Process Collection Appeals: Is It Constitutional? by Diane L. Fahey
  15. Appellate Court Briefs
    1. Patriot T. in Appellate Court
      1. Appellant's Opening Brief
      2. Appellant's Reply Brief
      3. Winning Appellant Decision
      4. Remand
      5. Post-Appeal Return to Show Cause
    2. Warren Patriot's Appellate Case
      1. Warren Patriot Magnificent CDPH Appeals Brief on Hearing & Schulz II
      2. IRS Response to Appeal Brief
      3. Warren's Motion to Dismiss
    3. Sheri Patriot's Appellate Case
      1. Sheri's Brief
      2. Ruling on Jurisdiction
      3. Sheri's Appellant Brief
    4. Harry's Appellant Court Case
      1. Issues Attached to IFP Application
  16. Appeals in U.S. District Court
    [Contains out-of-date motions and briefs]

Response to CDP Hearing

From: Trudy Shell
510 Shell Lane
Pomaria, SC 29126

July 6, 2006

M G Hallman Settlement Officer
1835 Assembly Street Suite 508
MDP 43
Columbia, SC 29201

RE: Trudy Shell SSN 123-45-6789; John Shell SSN 789-12-3456

Tax Court Docket # 20188-05L. 2002 Tax year

Ms Hallman,

My husband and I came to your office as instructed at 10am on July 5, 2006. Since you picked an early date (due to your office remodeling) rather than going to the end of the month as the Tax Court allowed, we did not have much time to prepare. We received the notice to be there at that set time, just 5 days earlier.

We dispute the tax liability because we didn’t have a chance to present our side in Tax Court. We have records of business expenses, deductions, telephone excise tax etc… As we told you many times, we didn’t receive the Notice of Deficiency. We keep our letters from the IRS in good order and respond promptly when required. Had we received a 90 day letter, we would have petitioned the Tax Court as the law allows. We requested in our CDPH last year that you present proof that we received the 90 days letters. You have not done so.

On July 5, 2006, you presented to us an e-mail from the post office which did not say or prove that we received the 90 day letters. The Post Office e-mail stated the some type of correspondence was sent from the IRS to our hometown, and not our specific address, on Sept 17, 2004. (Label tracking ID 7105567871)

In the past the IRS has sent notices and letters to us at an incorrect address even though they have our correct address on file. The mail sent to the incorrect address is not always forwarded to us. Congress was concerned that your tax agency frequently sent important notices knowingly to incorrect addresses. Therefore the elected representatives of the people enacted the CDPH law in §6330(c)(2)(B). Your office has failed in its duty and we request this case be sent back to the Audit Division so we can receive a new 90 day letter and have our day in court.

Your agency and/or the Post Office must have filed somewhere, the Return Receipt (the green card) which shows who received the alleged certified letter and what date it was received. Neither agency has furnished that receipt to us; therefore you have not met your burden of proof. Please send us a copy of the Return Receipt. Somebody has it.

We request Audit Reconsideration so we can present our documents and records. Also we request collection alternatives CNC (Currently Not Collectible) status as we are poor and cannot pay the assessment.

The levy is not appropriate because:

  1. The tax liability is not settled.
  2. I request Spousal Relief.
  3. Due to hardship we are entitled to CNC status.
  4. We request other collection alternatives including OIC

If you had not accelerated the date of our CDPH, we would have been able to complete your forms. We request more time to complete the OIC form, the financial statement and tax returns for previous years. We do not appreciate the rough treatment we received when we met with you and the persecution of our witness(s).

Also we expect reimbursement of our large expenses of our Petition to Tax Court following your previous determination to deny us our in-person hearing. The law says (as the tax court pointed out) we are entitled to a hearing. Your denial of our hearing entitlement was harassment and a crude attempt to deny us our rights.

Yours,

Trudy Shell

back to top

Home

For technical questions and assistance contact PNwebmaster